Dilapidations Report: What Landlords Send and How to Respond

Updated · By Office Refurbishment London · 5 min read

Short answer

What should a tenant do when they receive a dilapidations report?

Read it against your lease, then instruct your own surveyor to review every item for liability, remedy and cost. Respond in writing within the time set by the Dilapidations Protocol, usually 56 days from a terminal schedule and quantified demand. Do not agree figures or start works until the scope is clear.

When a dilapidations report lands, the headline figure can be alarming. It might be tens or hundreds of thousands of pounds, presented in a long schedule with lease clauses, photographs and costs. The good news is that the opening figure is rarely what is finally paid. A careful review usually finds items that are not breaches, remedies that go further than the lease requires and costs that are higher than the works would really cost. This guide explains what is in a typical report and how tenants should respond.

What should a tenant do when they receive a dilapidations report?
Section of a typical reportWhat it containsWhat tenants should check
Lease summaryRelevant clauses: repair, decoration, reinstatement, yield upAre the clauses quoted correctly and completely?
Itemised scheduleEach alleged breach, clause, remedy and costIs it a breach? Is the remedy proportionate?
PhotographsEvidence of conditionDo they show the actual premises and current condition?
CostingsRates and quantitiesAre rates realistic for London works?
Fees and VATProfessional fees, VAT treatmentIs VAT applicable? Are fees reasonable?
Loss of rentRent during works periodIs the period realistic?
Summary and demandTotal claimedIs it capped by diminution in value?

Landlord's report vs tenant's report

A landlord's report, normally a schedule of dilapidations, sets out the claim. A tenant's report, sometimes called a liability assessment, is commissioned by the tenant to estimate what they are actually liable for. Tenants often commission their own report before the landlord's arrives, using a dilapidations survey 12 to 18 months before lease end. Our guide to the schedule of dilapidations explains the format of the landlord's schedule item by item.

How to review a dilapidations report

For each item, ask four questions:

  1. Is it a breach? Is the tenant actually responsible under the lease, or does it fall to the landlord or service charge?
  2. Is the remedy right? Would a repair do, or is the landlord demanding replacement?
  3. Is the cost reasonable? Are quantities and rates realistic?
  4. Is it recoverable? Will the landlord actually suffer a loss, or will the works be superseded?

A schedule of condition from the start of the lease can be decisive in limiting repair liability.

Common issues found in reports

Common issues found in reports
IssueExample
BettermentClaiming new carpets where cleaning or repair would satisfy the lease
Landlord's itemsIncluding base-build plant maintained under the service charge
Excess remediesReplacing a whole ceiling for a few stained tiles
Inflated ratesRates well above competitive London pricing
Duplicate itemsRedecoration and repair priced twice
Superseded worksClaiming works the landlord plans to strip out in a refurbishment
Reinstatement not requiredAsking for removal of alterations the licence says may remain

Next step

Planning an office fit-out?

Send us your brief and we will be in touch to arrange a survey and a detailed, no-obligation quote.

Request a quote

How to respond

The Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in Relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy, usually called the Dilapidations Protocol, sets out how parties should exchange information. The tenant should normally respond within 56 days of receiving the landlord's terminal schedule and quantified demand, item by item, typically in a Scott schedule with columns for the tenant's comments and costs. See the Dilapidations Protocol.

Real costs vs surveyor estimates

Surveyors often estimate costs from rates databases. A price for the actual works, from the team that would carry them out, can be significantly different. Typical London ranges for office dilapidations works are around £8 to £20 per sq ft for strip-out, £15 to £35 per sq ft for reinstatement to Cat A and £4 to £10 per sq ft for redecoration, excluding VAT. Total office claims commonly fall around £25 to £65 per sq ft. We provide works-based prices that tenants and their surveyors can use in negotiations; see office dilapidations in London.

Section 18 and the cap on damages

A landlord's damages for disrepair at the end of a lease are capped by Section 18 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 at the diminution in the value of the landlord's reversion. If the landlord plans to demolish or substantially alter the premises, the claim for repairs may be reduced significantly or extinguished. See dilapidations claims and Section 18.

Should you do the works instead?

If the lease has not yet ended, carrying out works yourself can often reduce the total cost and close the issue. This works best when the scope is agreed with the landlord's surveyor, works are done to the required standard and there is enough time before lease end. See office strip-out in London.

{{CTA}}

VAT and dilapidations

A damages payment for dilapidations is normally outside the scope of VAT, while works you commission yourself attract VAT. See VAT on office refurbishment and dilapidations.

Accounting for a dilapidations report

When a report gives a reliable estimate of liability, businesses may need to recognise or update a provision. See dilapidations provision.

Tenant's response checklist

  • Lease, licences and schedule of condition gathered
  • Own surveyor instructed
  • Each item reviewed for breach, remedy, cost and recoverability
  • Works-based pricing obtained
  • Section 18 position considered
  • Response sent within the Protocol timescale
  • Negotiation strategy agreed: works, payment or a mix

Interim reports during the lease

Not every dilapidations report arrives at the end of a lease. Landlords can serve interim schedules during the term, particularly where a building is visibly deteriorating or a rent review or lease renewal is approaching. The response is different: the landlord is usually asking for repairs to be carried out rather than claiming damages. Acting promptly often keeps costs lower than leaving problems until the lease ends.

Negotiating a settlement

Most dilapidations claims settle by negotiation between surveyors. A typical sequence is the landlord's schedule, the tenant's response, a meeting or site visit to narrow the issues, revised figures and a settlement figure agreed in writing. Settlements are often a single payment in full and final settlement of all dilapidations claims. Where works have already been carried out, the settlement reflects what is left. Having realistic works prices on the table early often speeds the process and reduces the final figure.

Timing matters

The earlier you engage with a report, the more options you have. Before the lease ends, you can still carry out works. After it ends, the claim is for damages, and the landlord controls the premises. Tenants who respond promptly, keep to Protocol timescales and put realistic costs forward usually achieve better outcomes than those who wait.

How long a dilapidations report stays useful

A report reflects the premises on the day of inspection. If you commission one well before lease end, expect it to need a refresh once your plans firm up, because wear, alterations and landlord intentions change. Most tenants we work with get a first report 18 to 24 months out to set a budget and a provision, then a shorter update near the end once they know whether they are renewing, relocating or handing back. Keeping the original photo record alongside the update makes it easy to show what was already there and what has changed, which helps when the final figure is negotiated with the landlord's surveyor.

Get a works-based price

Send us the report or schedule and we will price the works as we would deliver them, to support your negotiations or to carry them out. Request a quote through our form.

Frequently asked questions

What is a dilapidations report?
A surveyor's document setting out a tenant's breaches of lease obligations and the cost of remedying them. Landlords' reports usually take the form of a schedule of dilapidations; tenants may commission their own liability report.
Is a dilapidations report the same as a schedule?
Often the terms are used interchangeably. Strictly, the schedule is the itemised list; a report may also include commentary, strategy and valuation advice.
Can a dilapidations report be challenged?
Yes. Tenants commonly challenge items that are not breaches, remedies that go beyond the lease, inflated costs and claims exceeding the loss to the landlord.
How long do I have to respond?
Under the Dilapidations Protocol, the tenant should usually respond within 56 days of receiving the landlord's terminal schedule and quantified demand.
Do I have to carry out the works on the report?
Not necessarily. At the end of a lease, claims are usually for damages; you can carry out works before the lease ends or negotiate a payment.

Related guides

Next step

Planning an office fit-out?

Send us your brief and we will be in touch to arrange a survey and a detailed, no-obligation quote.

Request a quote
Request a quote